Wisconsin Yellow Cheddar Aged 9 Years
Wisconsin Yellow Cheddar aged nine years, colored the traditional way with annatto for that deep golden hue. Wisconsin is one of the oldest cheddar-making places in the country, and a wheel that's been held this long is a real rarity.
The paste is firm and dry, breaking into clean shards under the knife with a crunch of tyrosine crystals running through. On the palate it opens sharp and concentrated, then pulls into brown butter and toasted nut through the middle, with a butterscotch sweetness underneath the salt. There's a peppery tingle on the back of the palate that builds the longer you chew, and the finish sticks around well past the swallow.
Nine-year cheddars are not common, most wheels don't make it past five before drying out or losing balance. This one is right in the sweet spot where the age has concentrated the flavor without crossing into harsh or chalky. Slice a thin shard and let it sit on the tongue for a second before chewing, the paste softens and the butterscotch comes through.
Product Information
Product Information
Shipping & Returns
Shipping & Returns

Wisconsin Yellow Cheddar Aged 9 Years
Wisconsin Yellow Cheddar Aged 9 Years
Wisconsin Yellow Cheddar aged nine years, colored the traditional way with annatto for that deep golden hue. Wisconsin is one of the oldest cheddar-making places in the country, and a wheel that's been held this long is a real rarity.
The paste is firm and dry, breaking into clean shards under the knife with a crunch of tyrosine crystals running through. On the palate it opens sharp and concentrated, then pulls into brown butter and toasted nut through the middle, with a butterscotch sweetness underneath the salt. There's a peppery tingle on the back of the palate that builds the longer you chew, and the finish sticks around well past the swallow.
Nine-year cheddars are not common, most wheels don't make it past five before drying out or losing balance. This one is right in the sweet spot where the age has concentrated the flavor without crossing into harsh or chalky. Slice a thin shard and let it sit on the tongue for a second before chewing, the paste softens and the butterscotch comes through.
Original: $32.00
-65%$32.00
$11.20Product Information
Product Information
Shipping & Returns
Shipping & Returns
Description
Wisconsin Yellow Cheddar aged nine years, colored the traditional way with annatto for that deep golden hue. Wisconsin is one of the oldest cheddar-making places in the country, and a wheel that's been held this long is a real rarity.
The paste is firm and dry, breaking into clean shards under the knife with a crunch of tyrosine crystals running through. On the palate it opens sharp and concentrated, then pulls into brown butter and toasted nut through the middle, with a butterscotch sweetness underneath the salt. There's a peppery tingle on the back of the palate that builds the longer you chew, and the finish sticks around well past the swallow.
Nine-year cheddars are not common, most wheels don't make it past five before drying out or losing balance. This one is right in the sweet spot where the age has concentrated the flavor without crossing into harsh or chalky. Slice a thin shard and let it sit on the tongue for a second before chewing, the paste softens and the butterscotch comes through.









